Envato: Get every type of asset for any type of project, and access to AI tools. Start now

AI Model Selection vs. Auto: Which should you use?

Compare manual AI Model Selection and Auto with Envato ModelMatch. Learn how each works, when to use them, and how to choose for your creative projects.

Ryan Cheng 12min read
A split image. On the left, a person wears futuristic glasses with text 'Model Selection'. On the right, a man with long hair and a beard eats cotton candy at a carnival with text 'Auto (ModelMatch)'. A green 'VS' is in the center.

When it comes to creating with AI, there’s more than one way to find the right model for your project.

Maybe you already have a favorite AI model. You’ve experimented with its capabilities, developed a workflow around it, and know exactly when you want to use it. Or perhaps you’ve got a creative idea and would rather focus on bringing it to life than comparing models, technical specifications, and credit costs.

With Envato, you can do both.

Model Selection lets you choose your preferred AI image and video models directly, while Auto, powered by Envato ModelMatch, uses your creative inputs to help match a model to the job.

Both give you a way to work with leading AI models, but they approach model choice differently.

So, when should you choose a model yourself, and when does Auto make sense? Let’s explore how each works, where they fit into your creative workflow, and how to decide which approach to use for your next project.

What’s the difference between Model Selection and Auto?

The main difference is how the AI model is chosen.

With manual Model Selection, you choose a specific model from Envato’s available catalog. You can explore its supported capabilities, review generation settings and credit costs, and decide which model you want to use.

With Auto, Envato ModelMatch works behind the scenes to help select a model suited to your creative task. It uses inputs such as your prompt, settings, and references to inform that selection.

Neither approach is inherently better than the other. Both are intentional ways to create, and the right fit depends on your project, workflow, and preferences.

Here’s how they compare.

Manual Model SelectionAuto with ModelMatch
How models are chosenYou select a specific model.ModelMatch helps match a model to your creative inputs.
Best suited toProjects where you have a preferred model or want to explore specific capabilities.Projects where you want your creative requirements to guide model matching.
Model visibilityYour selected model is visible on generated outputs.The underlying model used by Auto isn’t disclosed.
Credit costsVary depending on the selected model and settings.Uses blended pricing rather than model-specific pricing.
Model optionsChoose from a curated catalog of available models.Uses automated model routing, which may include a different set of models.
AvailabilityAvailable for eligible AI image and video generation.Remains the default option for eligible image and video generation.

The good news? You don’t have to commit to one approach.

You can choose a specific model for one project, switch to Auto for another, and experiment with both as your creative needs evolve.

What is manual AI Model Selection?

Manual Model Selection lets you choose a specific AI model when generating images and videos in Envato.

Rather than having a model selected automatically, you can browse a curated catalog of available models and decide which one you want to work with.

Each model has its own supported capabilities and generation settings. For image generation, these can include resolution, aspect ratios, and support for reference images. For video generation, capabilities may include sound, video duration, start and end frames, and reference inputs.

You can review these details alongside the model’s credit costs before generating.

Why choose an AI model manually?

As AI models become more specialized, creatives are discovering different ways to incorporate them into their workflows.

You might prefer a particular model because you’re familiar with how it interprets your prompts. Perhaps you want to explore a new model’s capabilities, or your project requires settings that aren’t supported by every available option.

Manual selection gives you the flexibility to make that choice yourself.

For example, imagine you’re developing a series of product images for a skincare campaign.

You’ve already experimented with several AI image models and found one that works well with your preferred prompts and visual references.

Rather than testing different models each time, you can select that model directly and continue developing your creative direction.

Alternatively, you might be exploring AI video generation and want to compare models that support start and end frames. Manual selection lets you review the available options and choose one that supports your requirements.

It’s a useful approach when your model preference or its specific capabilities are part of your creative process.

When manual Model Selection makes sense

Manual selection is worth exploring when:

  • You have a preferred model. You’ve worked with a particular model before and want to use it again.
  • You need specific capabilities. Your project requires a particular resolution, aspect ratio, reference input, or video feature.
  • You’re experimenting with AI models. You want to compare how different models interpret similar prompts.
  • You’re building a repeatable workflow. You want to incorporate a particular model into your creative process.
  • You want to review model-specific credit costs. You’re comparing the capabilities and credit requirements of available models.

For creatives who enjoy experimenting with different AI technologies, manual selection opens up more ways to explore what’s possible.

What is Auto with Envato ModelMatch?

Auto is Envato’s default model selection option, powered by ModelMatch.

Instead of choosing a specific AI model yourself, you provide your creative input, and ModelMatch selects a model suited to your task behind the scenes.

These inputs can include your prompt, generation settings, and references.

ModelMatch is informed by Envato’s AI specialists, available model capabilities, and real creative workflows. It helps manage the technology behind AI generation so you can focus on what you’re creating.

It’s important to note that ModelMatch isn’t a separate tool you need to configure or interact with. It’s the technology behind the Auto option in Envato.

How does ModelMatch work?

Let’s say you’re creating a campaign image for a new lifestyle brand.

You’ve written a detailed prompt describing the visual style, composition, and lighting. You’ve also added reference images and selected the settings you need for your output.

With Auto selected, ModelMatch uses those creative inputs to help choose an appropriate AI model behind the scenes.

You don’t need to research the available models or compare their technical capabilities before starting.

Instead, your creative brief guides the process.

ModelMatch doesn’t guarantee that every generation will produce the best possible result. AI outputs can vary, and different models may interpret creative instructions differently.

Its role is to help match your creative task to suitable AI technology without requiring you to manage every model decision yourself.

Why use Auto with ModelMatch?

AI is evolving quickly. New models emerge, capabilities change, and the number of available options continues to grow.

For creatives, keeping up with those changes can mean spending time researching models, comparing features, and evaluating which technology suits a particular project.

But not every creative job needs to start with that research.

Auto offers another way to work.

You can focus on the visual direction, creative brief, and desired output, while ModelMatch manages the model selection process behind the scenes.

This is particularly useful when you’re exploring an unfamiliar creative format or when your project requirements matter more than the choice of a particular model.

The benefit of ModelMatch and Envato’s pricing approach

Model choice isn’t the only consideration when working with AI.

On many AI platforms, different models also have varying credit costs. That means choosing a model can involve comparing both its capabilities and the cost of using it.

Envato approaches this differently with Auto.

ModelMatch helps manage model selection behind the scenes, while Envato’s blended pricing means you don’t need to make a separate model-specific pricing decision for each generation.

Rather than comparing the credit costs of different underlying models, you can review the credit cost associated with your Auto generation and its settings.

That doesn’t mean every generation costs the same number of credits. Costs can still vary depending on what you’re creating and the settings you choose.

The benefit is that the underlying model decision doesn’t need to become another pricing comparison.

Together, ModelMatch and Envato’s pricing approach help make access to leading AI models more straightforward, even as the technology continues to evolve.

When Auto makes sense

Auto is worth considering when:

  • Your creative idea comes first. You have a clear brief but no particular model preference.
  • You’re exploring something new. You’re experimenting with a creative format or workflow you haven’t tried before.
  • You want your inputs to guide model matching. Your prompt, settings, and references define what you need.
  • You don’t need a specific model. You’re open to different technologies that support your creative task.
  • You want to avoid model-by-model pricing decisions. You’d rather work with Auto’s blended pricing than compare the credit costs of individual models.

Auto isn’t a lesser-control option. It’s a deliberate way to create when you want your creative task to lead the model selection process.

How to decide between Model Selection and Auto

The choice doesn’t need to be complicated.

Start by thinking about what matters most for your next project.

Choose manual Model Selection when you have a model in mind

If you’ve already developed a preference for a particular AI model, manual selection lets you work with it directly.

It’s also useful when you want to experiment with a specific model or explore capabilities that support your creative requirements.

For example, if you’re producing a video and want to test a particular model’s start- and end-frame capabilities, manual selection lets you do so.

Choose Auto when your creative task is the starting point

If you have a creative idea but no model preference, Auto lets your prompt, settings, and references guide the model matching process.

It’s a useful approach when you’re exploring new creative territory or when you want to focus on your brief rather than researching different models.

For example, if you’re generating concept imagery for a campaign and are open to which AI model is used, Auto can help match a model to your creative inputs.

Use both as your projects evolve

You don’t have to stick with one approach.

You might start with Auto when exploring a new idea, then manually select a model for another generation to test a specific capability.

Or you might use a preferred model for an established workflow, then switch to Auto for a completely different creative task.

The flexibility to move between them means your approach can adapt as your projects evolve.

How to switch between Model Selection and Auto in Envato

Both options are available within eligible AI image and video generation workflows.

Here’s how to get started.

  1. Open Envato’s AI generation experience and choose whether you’re creating an image or video. Start with the creative outcome you want to achieve.
  2. Explore the model selection options. You’ll see Auto alongside the available models for your chosen generation type.
  3. Select a specific model if you have one in mind. Review its supported capabilities, settings, and credit costs before generating.
  4. Choose Auto if you’d like ModelMatch to help select a model based on your creative inputs. Auto remains the default option.
  5. Add your prompt, references, and supported generation settings. Describe your creative direction clearly so your inputs reflect what you’re trying to create.
  6. Generate your content and review the result. For another generation, you can select a different model or switch back to Auto.

Model Selection is available across all Envato subscription plans for eligible AI image and video generation.

Tips for getting more from both approaches

Whether you’re choosing a model manually or using Auto, a few creative habits can help you make the most of AI generation.

Write prompts with a clear creative direction

Your prompt plays an important role in communicating what you want to create.

Rather than writing a broad instruction such as “Create a product image,” describe the composition, lighting, visual style, and other details that matter to your project.

For example:

“Create an editorial product photograph of a clear glass perfume bottle on a pale stone pedestal, with warm afternoon sunlight, soft shadows, and a minimalist luxury aesthetic.”

A more detailed brief gives you a clearer starting point for evaluating the result, whether you’re using manual selection or Auto.

Use references to communicate your vision

Reference images can help guide visual direction, composition, and other creative details.

Different models support different reference capabilities, so review the available settings when manually choosing a model.

With Auto, supported references can also help inform ModelMatch’s selection process.

Experiment with different approaches

There’s value in trying both manual selection and Auto.

For example, you might generate an image using a preferred model, then try the same creative brief with Auto.

The results won’t necessarily be directly comparable if the supported settings differ, but experimenting can help you understand which approach suits your workflow.

Review credit costs before generating

Credit costs vary depending on your selected model or generation settings.

With manual selection, review the model-specific credit requirements.

With Auto, review the credit cost associated with your generation settings.

That way, you can make informed decisions about how you use your available credits.

Your creative vision, your way

There’s no single way to create with AI. Some projects start with a familiar model and a clear set of requirements. Others begin with an idea, a few references, and the freedom to explore.

With Envato, you can choose the approach that suits your work.

Model Selection lets you work with the AI models you prefer, explore new capabilities, and make model choice part of your creative process.

Auto, powered by Envato ModelMatch, helps match a model to your creative task behind the scenes, while Envato’s blended pricing means you don’t need to compare the costs of individual underlying models.

Both approaches give you access to leading AI technology, with the flexibility to move between them as your projects change.

Because the goal isn’t to spend more time choosing AI. It’s to spend more time creating with it.

Start creating with Envato today.

Model Selection and ModelMatch FAQs

Related Posts